BeautifulSoup vs. Scrapy: Which One To Use For Your Scraper And Why Proxies Matter

If you want to write a web scraper, many tools and programs are available that can help you. One of the most important is a scraping library or framework. These kinds of tools give you a prebuilt set of commands that you can use to target information on a page and collect it efficiently.

Most programmers recommend two main toolsets for writing bots: BeautifulSoup and Scrapy. Here’s what you need to know about these toolsets, comparing BeautifulSoup vs. Scrapy, and when to use each one with high-quality proxies.

What Is Scrapy?

Scrapy is a “framework,” or an all-in-one tool that you can use to run a web crawler and scraper. It runs in Python. By installing and running Scrapy, you can write a web scraper without any other libraries or programs. Every command you might need is built into the framework, from visiting a site to finding and saving page elements.

Scrapy is also extensible, meaning that you can add extra features if it’s not enough on its own. For instance, many programmers choose to pair Scrapy with a headless browser to scrape JavaScript and asynchronous requests.

The one downside to Scrapy is that it’s relatively complex. That makes it great for large projects and experienced programmers, but it can be overwhelming for simple tasks if you’ve never written a scraper before.

What Is BeautifulSoup?

BeautifulSoup is a little different. Instead of acting as a whole framework, BeautifulSoup is a Python parsing library. On its own, BeautifulSoup can’t crawl websites. It’s a dedicated library that lets your program interact with and understand web pages in many different ways.

The biggest draw of BeautifulSoup is how easy it is to use. The commands are simple, and overall the library just works. It’s easy to integrate into any Python scraping program and flexible enough to gather many kinds of information.

Since it’s just a parsing library, though, BeautifulSoup requires you to use a crawling tool like the requests library to build a fully-functional scraper. If you’re planning on writing a large program, using BeautifulSoup can add some time to the process since you’ll need to integrate it with multiple other libraries. Still, the library’s simplicity makes it great for smaller projects, especially if you’re new to scraping.

Scrapy vs. BeautifulSoup: Pros and Cons

The popularity contest of BeautifulSoup vs. Scrapy shows that both tools have their uses. To compare them better, you need to understand their benefits and drawbacks:

Scrapy pros:

• A single consolidated framework that doesn’t require any extra tools
• Faster to write once you get the hang of it
• Faster to run once it’s written

Scrapy cons:

• More complicated to learn
• Possible overkill for small projects

BeautifulSoup pros:

• Flexible and easy to add to scraping programs
• Faster to learn
• Simple to write small programs

BeautifulSoup cons:

• Requires other tools to crawl websites
• Slower to run because of the extra tools needed
• More difficult to write large programs

Scrapy vs. BeautifulSoup: Which One To Use

If you’re choosing between Scrapy and BeautifulSoup, your decision should probably be based on your experience and the size of your project.

If you’re familiar with Python or you’ve written scrapers before, then Scrapy is probably your best bet. You have the knowledge to make the most of all of Scrapy’s different features and commands. That means you won’t waste time learning the framework, and you can take advantage of Scrapy’s speed and flexibility. Scrapy is also the best option for large-scale scrapers since its speed and feature set leads to quicker results.

Meanwhile, if you’re relatively new to Python and scraping overall, then BeautifulSoup is a good choice. It’s easy to use and easy to run. Integrating other libraries into your program will help you learn more about how scrapers work. BeautifulSoup is also the simpler option if you’re writing a small program since there are fewer features to confuse you.

The Importance of Using Proxies With Beautiful Soup and Scrapy

Of course, there’s more to a good scraper than a parsing tool. When your scraping program crawls websites on a large scale, it’s at risk of getting blocked by overenthusiastic anti-hacking security measures. If you want your scraper to succeed, you need to protect it with high-quality proxies.

Proxies act as a shield for your IP address. Most websites block suspicious visitors based on their IP addresses. By using a proxy, sites have a harder time seeing your IP address while you’re web scraping.

There are three kinds of proxies that you can use to protect your bot. The first is a data center proxy. These proxies are housed in data centers and don’t have a connection to a residential address. Data center proxies are inexpensive but more likely to get detected.

The next is a residential proxy. These proxies are issued by an ISP and connected to a residential address, so they look like “real” users. That makes residential proxies more expensive than data center but they’re also harder to spot. That makes them great for larger or high-importance scrapes.

Finally, ISP proxies are issued by an ISP but housed in a data center. They cost a little more, but they’re the best of both worlds of data center and residential proxies. They have the efficiency of data center proxies and the authority of residential proxies.

No matter what kind of scraping program you’re writing, it’s essential to use one of these proxy types. They protect your actual IP address from getting permanently banned from the sites you’re trying to study. You can use proxies to keep your research on track and your IP address unaffected.

Choosing Beautifulsoup vs. Scrapy To Use With Rayobyte Proxies

When you’re comparing BeautifulSoup vs. Scrapy, you’ll find both are excellent tools with many die-hard programmer fans. Scrapy is great for experienced Python programmers and large projects, while BeautifulSoup is ideal for smaller tasks and new coders. Integrating these tools with Rayobyte proxies can make your next scraper effective and secure. You can start writing your next scraper today and trust Rayobyte proxies to keep your IP address and bot safe.

The information contained within this article, including information posted by official staff, guest-submitted material, message board postings, or other third-party material is presented solely for the purposes of education and furtherance of the knowledge of the reader. All trademarks used in this publication are hereby acknowledged as the property of their respective owners.